Greensill misled German regulator on insurance coverage deal, IAG claims

Unlock the Editor’s Digest without cost

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.

A big insurer of Greensill Capital has alleged the failed lender deceived German regulators in an try to cut back the capital necessities of its Bremen-based unit.

Insurance coverage Australia Group, which is being sued by Greensill traders nursing billions of {dollars} of losses, has accused the defunct supply-chain finance group of concealing the very fact it had agreed to fund its personal insurance coverage claims when it introduced a credit score insurance coverage assure to the regulator.

The transfer was “meant to deceive the regulator and was fraudulent”, IAG stated in a court docket submitting final week.

Greensill insurers are combating claims for credit score insurance coverage payouts protecting loans prolonged by the failed lender after which packaged up for traders.

The administrator for Greensill Financial institution, the group’s German banking unit, which held a few of the insured notes, is amongst entities suing insurers as a part of key proceedings in Australia. Sydney-based IAG, which denies legal responsibility, argues that insurance coverage provided on its behalf was invalid.

Within the submitting, IAG stated that Lex Greensill, the Australian financier who ran the group, approached its key underwriter, Greg Brereton, in 2018 to suggest an association that may permit its German banking entity to make use of credit score insurance coverage as a threat mitigant beneath native rules.

Brereton was an government at underwriting company Bond & Credit score Co, which was then 50 per cent owned by IAG and issued insurance coverage insurance policies on its behalf.

If Greensill Financial institution wanted to say on its credit score insurance coverage, Greensill Capital would allegedly advance funds to BCC which might then pay that quantity to Greensill Financial institution inside 5 days. This was then formalised by an extension to the coverage that IAG says was “silent as to the proposed funding association” and, it provides, was agreed with out searching for its consent.

In late April 2019, simply days after Japanese insurance coverage group Tokio Marine introduced it had acquired BCC, Lex Greensill requested that Brereton affirm the association in a letter to be shared with BaFin, the German monetary watchdog, in line with the submitting. Brereton supplied it, in line with IAG.

Individuals with data of the matter confirmed such a letter was shared with the regulator however stated that no settlement between BCC and Greensill Capital was disclosed.

IAG argues Greensill’s conduct was “more likely to mislead Greensill Financial institution’s regulator that [IAG] had agreed to pay claims inside 5 days when it had not and concerned the deliberate hiding from BaFin that GCUK was in actual fact funding any claims cost”. 

“The correct inference within the circumstances is that the conduct was meant to deceive the regulator and was fraudulent,” it wrote.

BaFin’s determination to approve credit score insurance coverage as a threat mitigant allowed Greensill Financial institution to class its mortgage guide as safer. In 2019, two years earlier than Greensill’s collapse, German ranking company Scope gave the group’s German financial institution unit an investment-grade ranking, citing a “giant credit score insurance coverage contract” authorised by BaFin as a purpose for its improved capital ratio.

BaFin revoked the capital reduction in 2021 within the wake of an audit into Greensill Financial institution, in line with individuals aware of the small print.

Joachim Kühne, a lawyer working for Greensill Financial institution’s German administrator, informed the Monetary Instances that the administrator was assessing IAG’s allegations. 

BaFin, Tokio Marine, IAG and a spokesperson for Lex Greensill declined to remark. Authorized representatives for Brereton didn’t instantly reply to an FT request for remark. Brereton has additionally denied legal responsibility within the Australian proceedings and stated he was misled by each Greensill and IAG.

Bremen prosecutors, who’re working the German felony investigation into Greensill Financial institution’s 2021 demise, informed the FT that they’ve been scrutinising the group’s insurance coverage preparations. They stated they beforehand didn’t learn about particulars outlined in IAG’s submitting. 

Greensill Financial institution had €3.5bn of deposits when it collapsed, with savers lured in by its comparatively excessive rates of interest. Whereas most of those depositors have been coated by an insurance coverage scheme, €500mn held by municipalities was not coated. These cities and small cities are nonetheless but to reclaim their funds two and a half years later.

Some have opted to promote on their claims for a fraction of their face worth, with the municipality of Botzingen disclosing earlier this yr that it had offered its personal for 25 cents on the euro.